A Reply to Climate Sceptics

I feel grateful for Donald R. Prothero’s “How We Know Global Warming is Real and Human Caused” in Skeptic Magazine 17:2(2012) 14-22. Prothero first enumerates the evidence concerning anthropogenic global warming (carbon dioxide increase, melting polar ice caps, melting glaciers, sea level rise), then critically analyses the main arguments of climate change critics (particularly those who will admit the changes but not human responsibility), and ends with the important question “Why do people continue to question the reality of climate change?”.

To answer to this last question he points to the financial power and interests of “right-wing institutes and the energy lobby” and shows that we are facing here “a purely political controversy, rather than a scientific debate”.

I am particularly grateful that the article begins with a quote of Richard Feynman: “Reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled”. Amongst scientists there is near unanimity concerning anthropogenic climate warming, while they agree and push that the matter be pursued even more thoroughly than the current Best Science Available (BAS – scientists will always, I think, agree on that point and, therefore, welcome articulate and well founded scientific debate). I fully agree with Prothero that “climate deniers have a lot of (…) things in common with creationists and other anti-science movements”. Let’s hope that political leadership will lend a better and more responsible ear to those scientists who attempt to be true to reality instead of attempting to obscure the facts out of political and financial interests. As a Roman Catholic theologian and Jesuit I also continue to hope that both the Churches and religions as a whole, as well as the worldwide religious institutions will assume their responsibilities and put their capacities at the best use to provide a decent response to the challenges of anthropogenic climate warming.

Advertisements

One response to “A Reply to Climate Sceptics

  1. ““Why do people continue to question the reality of climate change?”.

    Not many people actually do, what they deny is human responsibility. You can attempt to blame it on financial interests if you like but in reality the science attributing responsibility to human activity is just not very strong.

    “.. melting polar ice caps, melting glaciers, sea level rise), ”

    Melting ice caps, glaciers and sea level rise are merely evidence that the climate changes, they are not evidence that Co2 is the cause.

    “I fully agree with Prothero that “climate deniers have a lot of (…) things in common with creationists and other anti-science movements”.”

    Hmm, you seem to be unaware of the similarities between the global climate alarmist movement and many new age religions. When you view climate alarmism as a faith or quasi-religion, alarmists behave like members of any faith. No matter what evidence you present which contradicts the alarmist faith, the faithful merely ignore it and carry on undaunted. This behavior virtually defines faith.

    Climate alarmism is a faith which possesses a god (Gaia earth), a good book (AR4 report), an organization (IPCC), a devil (CO2), priests (climate scientists), apostles (A Gore), sinners (humanity), sinful behavior (carbon emissions), and an apocolypse (climate disaster). The only things missing I think are churches and a martyr. Someday they will have these as well.

    In a few centuries their church ceilings might have frescos of early desciples like Gore and Pachaurie. Frightening thought really.

    You might want to consider some of this when you are promoting this alrternate faith.

    cheers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s